New York Highway Use Tax vs Florida: Why Florida Trucks Pay No Mileage Tax
Table Of Contents
-
Introduction
-
The Quick Answer
-
What the New York Highway Use Tax Is
-
Which Trucks Pay It
-
What Florida Charges Instead
-
Registration and Decals
-
Short Visits to Each State
-
Returns and Filing
-
Side-by-Side Comparison
-
Common Mistakes to Avoid
-
Why Many Trucking Companies Choose Our Service
-
FAQ
Introduction
Many carriers run the I-95 corridor between New York and Florida every week. The freight is the same at both ends, but the tax bill isn't.
New York charges heavy trucks for every mile they drive on its public highways. Florida doesn't. This guide compares the New York Highway Use Tax with Florida's approach, so you know what each state collects and which credentials your truck needs before it reaches the state line.
The Quick Answer
The New York Highway Use Tax (HUT) is a mileage tax based on a truck's weight and the miles it runs on New York public highways. Florida has no mileage tax on trucks. In Florida, a carrier pays through fuel tax and registration, using IFTA and IRP or a Florida Fuel Permit and Florida Trip Permit.
What the New York Highway Use Tax Is
New York: Under Tax Law Section 503, the tax is based on the gross weight of each motor vehicle and the number of miles it is operated on New York public highways. Rates are set in mills per mile, and one mill is one-tenth of a cent. A heavier truck pays a higher rate for each mile.
Florida: Florida has no tax measured by weight and miles.
What it means for you: In New York, every taxable mile goes on a return. In Florida, miles matter for fuel tax and IRP, not for a separate mileage tax.
Which Trucks Pay It
New York: The New York Highway Use Tax applies to:
-
A truck or tractor with a gross weight over 18,000 pounds, alone or in combination,
-
A truck with an unloaded weight over 8,000 pounds, or
-
A tractor with an unloaded weight over 4,000 pounds.
Florida: No Florida mileage tax applies at any weight. Instead, a qualified motor vehicle needs IFTA or a Florida Fuel Permit. That generally means a power unit with two axles over 26,000 pounds, three or more axles, or a combination over 26,000 pounds.
What it means for you: New York reaches lighter trucks. A 20,000-pound box truck owes HUT in New York but may need no fuel credential in Florida.
What Florida Charges Instead
New York: A truck in New York pays HUT on top of fuel tax and registration.
Florida: Florida collects road money through two main credentials:
-
Fuel tax. Under Section 207.003, Florida's motor fuel use tax applies to each gallon of motor fuel used to propel a qualified motor vehicle in Florida, including fuel bought in another state.
-
Registration. Out-of-state apportionable vehicles pay Florida through IRP, or buy a Florida Trip Permit when Florida isn't on the cab card.
What it means for you: Florida taxes the fuel your truck burns, while New York also taxes the miles and the weight behind them.
Registration and Decals
New York: A carrier subject to HUT needs a HUT certificate of registration and a decal for each vehicle. The application is Form TMT-1.
Florida: There is no mileage tax decal in Florida. An IFTA carrier displays its IFTA decals, and a carrier without IFTA carries a Florida Fuel Permit.
What it means for you: Before a New York run, check the HUT decal. Before a Florida run, check the IFTA decals or fuel permit.
Short Visits to Each State
New York: A carrier that only occasionally runs in New York can get a HUT trip certificate instead of a full registration. The Tax Department lists the fee as $25. A trip certificate doesn't require the regular HUT returns.
Florida: A truck that visits now and then uses a Florida Trip Permit for registration and a Florida Fuel Permit for fuel tax. Both expire 10 days after issuance.
What it means for you: One New York trip can need a trip permit, a fuel permit, and a HUT trip certificate. One Florida trip needs a trip permit and a fuel permit.
Returns and Filing
New York: The New York Highway Use Tax return is Form MT-903. Carriers file quarterly at first, and the Tax Department moves them to monthly if HUT was over $12,000 last year, or annual if it was $1,200 or less. A return is due even if no tax is due.
Florida: There is no mileage tax return in Florida. IFTA carriers report Florida miles and gallons on their quarterly IFTA return through their base state. Carriers using a Florida Fuel Permit pay when they buy the permit.
What it means for you: A New York HUT account adds its own filing calendar. Florida adds no mileage tax return.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | New York | Florida |
|---|---|---|
| Mileage tax | Highway Use Tax | None |
| Based on | Weight and miles | Fuel used (fuel tax) |
| Weight line | Over 18,000 lb gross | Over 26,000 lb or 3+ axles (fuel) |
| Credential | HUT certificate and decal | IFTA decals or fuel permit |
| Short visit | HUT trip certificate, $25 | Trip and fuel permits, 10 days |
| Return | MT-903, quarterly at first | Quarterly IFTA return |
| Toll miles | Thruway toll miles excluded | No mileage tax to reduce |
Common Mistakes to Avoid
-
Assuming IFTA covers New York HUT. It doesn't. HUT is separate.
-
Skipping HUT on a lighter truck. The gross weight line is 18,000 pounds.
-
Looking for a Florida mileage tax. Florida doesn't have one.
-
Forgetting zero-mile HUT returns. New York requires a return even when no tax is due.
-
Counting toll-paid Thruway miles. They're excluded from HUT.
Why Many Trucking Companies Choose Our Service
New York Trucking Online helps carriers set up their New York Highway Use Tax account, keep certificates and decals current, and get the right permits before a trip, so the New York leg of an I-95 run stays covered.
-
Trip permit: $105
-
Fuel permit: $115
We provide support 24/7 and also work weekends and holidays.
or
FAQ
Does Florida have a mileage tax like the New York Highway Use Tax?
No. Florida collects through fuel tax and registration instead.
Which trucks pay the New York Highway Use Tax?
Trucks over 18,000 pounds gross, trucks over 8,000 pounds unloaded, and tractors over 4,000 pounds unloaded.
Does IFTA cover New York HUT?
No. HUT needs its own certificate, decal,l and returns.
What does a Florida truck need for one New York trip?
A HUT trip certificate, plus registration and fuel credentials such as a trip permit and fuel permit.
Are Thruway miles taxed under HUT?
Not on toll-paid portions of the Thruway.
For more information, visit the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance and the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles.